2007 - C.C. Sabathia, Cleveland

2006 - Johan Santana-x, Minnesota

2005 - Bartolo Colón, Los Angeles

2004 - Johan Santana-x, Minnesota

2003 - Roy Halladay, Toronto

2002 - Barry Zito, Oakland

2001 - Roger Clemens, Nueva York

2000 - Pedro Martínez-x, Boston

1999 - Pedro Martínez-x, Boston

1998 - Roger Clemens-x, Toronto

1997 - Roger Clemens, Toronto

1996 - Pat Hentgen, Toronto

1995 - Randy Johnson, Seattle

1994 - David Cone, Kansas City

1993 - Jack McDowell, Chicago

1992 - Dennis Eckersley, Oakland

1991 - Roger Clemens, Boston

1990 - Bob Welch, Oakland

1989 - Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City

1988 - Frank Viola, Minnesota

1987 - Roger Clemens, Boston

1986 - Roger Clemens-x, Boston

1985 - Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City

1984 - Willie Hernández, Detroit

1983 - LaMarr Hoyt, Chicago

1982 - Pete Vuckovich, Milwaukee

1981 - Rollie Fingers, Milwaukee

1980 - Steve Stone, Baltimore

1979 - Mike Flanagan, Baltimore

1978 - Ron Guidry-x, Nueva York

1977 - Sparky Lyle, Nueva York

1976 - Jim Palmer, Baltimore

1975 - Jim Palmer, Baltimore

1974 - Catfish Hunter, Oakland

1973 - Jim Palmer, Baltimore

1972 - Gaylord Perry, Cleveland

1971 - Vida Blue, Oakland

1970 - Jim Perry, Minnesota

1969 - (Empate) Mike Cuellar, Baltimore, y Denny McLain, Detroit

1968 - Denny McLain-x, Detroit

1967 - Jim Lonborg, Boston

1964 - Dean Chance, Los Angeles

1961 - Whitey Ford, Nueva York

1959 - Early Wynn, Chicago

1958 - Bob Turley, Nueva York

x-decisión unánime

NOTA: Entre 1956-1966 se hacía sólo una selección en ambas ligas.